Hidden Treasures of a Forgotten Bulgarian State
Milosh Siderov
In London on the 14th of September 1981 Sotheby exhibited
the Parke Bernet & Co. Collection of gold and silver objects
referring to them as an "Avar Treasure" - a treasure,
which shows amazing similarity with those found at Vrap, Albania
in 1901 and currently kept at the Metropolitan Museum of Art,
New York.
Until then specialists inadvertently faced the question:
- Was the Vrap treasure stolen by some unknown ruler, removed
and finally by chance buried at Vrap, amidst the hilly Shar
region, 30 km southeast of Dures, present day Albania, or was
it made in the same territory where the treasure was originally
found and consequently belonged to some local ruler?
The second hypothesis appeared less plausible .
The study of the golden objects from Vrap points to what
is known as "Royal Insignia", attributes which the
ruler alone is entitled to wear and use.
Judging from the style they were made and used by the
Avar khaganate - the Union of the Obrai ("Pseudo-Avars"),
Bulgarian Slavs , and Kotragoi of Panonia and Srem. For a certain
period this state also included parts of the former Roman provinces
of Dalmatia, Prevalitania, Dardania and Ilyria, in other words
an association coming down from present-day Hungary, to the southwest
of present day Albania.
Once Sotheby exhibited the new treasures, which could
also could have belonged to some of the Khagans of the Avar-Koutrigur
state, encompassing the Panonian plains , Srem, Banat, Baranya,
Slavonia, together with present day Bosnia and Herzegovina,
Dalmatia and some parts of Monte Negro, Albania and Macedonia
the question is increasingly intriguing. What we have is a powerful
state. The confines of this state are indicated by archeological
finds from Brestivec (Slavonia), Chobe (on the Bosnia river)
Pliskov , close to Knin (Northern Dalmatia), the Danubian plain
(Western Herzegovina) , Sudikovo on the Lim river (Monte Negro)
and at last by the finds in Albania together with those documents
where Episcopia Hunabia is mentioned in Albania and Episcopia
Avarorum in Monte Negro.
The new golden and silver objects , on show in London
were examined by Ioachim Werner, the internationally known German
archeologist. In order to establish their mysterious origins
he visited Albania, Vrap, the original site, and confirmed beyond
doubt the location of the discovery of the new sensational royal
treasure. I.Werner carried out additional studies and made an
exhaustive analysis both of the treasure and the site. Subsequently
he published a study in Tirana on the Vrap treasure , which had
already won international fame, and a separate monography in
Vienna on the new treasure , shown for the first time in Sotheby.
The town of Erseka ( a small town near the Albanian-Greek
border , 80 km from Ohrid, 120 km southeast of the golden Khan's
treasure of Vrap) is the site where the sensational golden objects,
exhibited in London in 1981, were found . Erseka is situated
in a valley on the western slopes of Gramos mountain . The
valley is in the upper stretches of Osumi river and a continuation
of the Korca valley, which in line is a continuation of the Ohrid
valley.
Specialists on the Vrap and Erseka treasures refer to
them as as " archeological finds of a European standing".
It is interesting to note that they are unique cast gold belt
applications . On one of the sections of the belt of the this
prince , found in the royal treasure of Vrap (Albania) we find
engraved the sign of a clan , identical to the sign on a belt
of a prince from Osora ( a site between the Danube and Balaton
lake in Hungary) ; this gave ground for J.Kovacevich ,the Serbian
archeologists, to suppose that the Khan's clan sign (from the
treasures from Vrap and Erseka) is identical with sign from grave
of Malaja Pereschepina , from Ozora. Sufficient proof exists identifying
it as the sign of Bulgarian Royal clan of Doulo.
Werner notes that the treasuries of "Avar rulers"
were always " in close proximity to the Khagan", hence
Vrap and Erseka indicate a central region , a seat of a ruler.
Historical evidence provides us with additional information (The
Addenda to the Chronicle of Manasses, The Wonders of St.Dimitrius).
We know for certain that the rulers here , Bulgarian Khans Dragon
and Kuber from the Doulo clan , (respectively in the 5th and
7th c.) had settled in Bitola Region, Ohrid Region - Prespa and
Korca, i.e. this was the Devol Region, where Erseka is also located.
This is also confirmed by Khan Tervel's rock inscription at
Madara , which speaks of "the uncles from Thessalonike",
i.e. the Kuber clan, which controlled the regions north of Thessalonike.
Considering the relief there is substantial ground to
suppose that the name " The lower Ohrid lands" ("Dolnaja
zemja Ohridska") , occuring in the marginal notes to the
Chronicle of Manasses , describing events during the reign of
Emperor
Anastasius (491-517) , refers exactly to the Ersek, Dolna
Prespa and Korcha valley (Devol) . Why do we draw attention to
these details? Because the Chronicle of Manasses namely speaks
of Dolnaja zemja Ohridska, as a territory of the first lasting
settlement of the Bulgarian Slavs and the Kotragoi , as well
as their military and political stabilization during the 6th c.
(after 495, 507 and in particular after 586) . Here are the marginal
notes in the Chronicle of Manasses:
In the reign of Tzar Anastasius
the Bulgarians began to take these lands
and gradually began to build a home (country),
as far as the Ohrid lands, and afterwards
they conquered all the Ohrid lands
Werner's study , P.Lemerl's research and V.Popovic's studies
lead to the conviction, that these objects , which make up the
oldest and largest collection related with the state of the "Pseudo
Obrai", i.e. the Panonian-Illyrian Bulgarian Kotragoi,
were made in a Bulgarian state, so far overlooked by historians
- the state of Berzitia. The supposition is that this country
included the territory between the Vardar river and the Adriatic
, to the west , with the exception of the Byzantine fortified
towns of Thessalonike and Dures (the Medieval Dyrrachium). To
the south this state reached the Pind mountains, and to the
north up to the Lim river, a tributary of the Drina. The valuable
treasure found at Vrap, which is above all evidence of the culture
of this forgotten Bulgarian state are kept, as we already mentioned,
at the Metropolitan Museum of Arts in New York, while those from
Erseka , and exhibited at the Sotheby Gallery are in an unknown
private collection.
Once historical sources , later supported by valuable
archeological finds suggest the existence of an organized Bulgarian
state in Western Macedonia, Epirus and Albania, the natural question
arises: who created it, and who were its rulers? The answer may
be found in Istorija slavjanobolgarskaja, of Paisii of
Chilendar, and the Day Book of Yovcho Pop Nikolov.
Both Paisii and Pop Nikolov refer to two names of rulers.
In Paisii's Istorija slavjanobolgarskaja they are the
"two brothers" King Vukic and King Dragic. Yovcho pop
Nikolov renders the names as Prince Voleg and Prince Dragon .
According to his "Chronicle" they reigned in 502 and
530 . Paisii's History has the following about the Bulgarians
from Srem and Banat Region (called the First Avar Khaganate):
"The Bulgarians , who were along the Danube, had a King called
Vukic. In 450 they attacked King Dogobarda, defeated him, and
killed him in battle, captured his lands and returned to their
own lands."
Bulgarian Slavs settled in the "Lower Ohrid lands"
(Ilyrian Bulgaria) led by Dragic (according to Paissii) or Dragon
(according to Y.pop Nikolov). Paissii's historical record runs
as follows: " In 495 the Bulgarian Prince was called Dragic.
They attacked Frangia and Ilyria, defeated the Greek army, led
by its mightiest among them Tzar Anastasius, killed 400,000 men
and took many lands and many people. Tzar Anastasius sent much
gold to the Bulgarians and numerous gifts and bought peace. The
said Dragic was the first to have received tribute from the
Greek King Anastasius". The year of the Bulgarian invasion
in Ilyria (495) which falls in the fourth year of the reign of
Anastasius in Byzantium appears to be quite realistic. Hence
we can say that Dragic , i.e. Dragon was the founder of the western
Bulgarian state ("the Lower Ohrid Land","Ilyrian
Bulgaria", Berzitia, Kotokion).
Further waves of "pseudo-avars", i.e. Slav-Bulgarians
, close to Dyrrachium (present day Dures), Ohrid, Devol (present
day Korca) and the Epirus Region between 586 and 588 are evidenced
in the so called Vita Sc.Pancratii, as well as in the Chronicle
of Monevasius, which states that the "pseudo-avars"
i.e. Bulgarian Slavs conquered the region of the Old Epirus,
in their second campaign to Greece in 588. Thus, having ruled
northern New Epirus in the course of some twenty years . they
further conquered and settled the whole region of Epirus (Epirus
vetus and Epirus novus) , including the western part of Macedonia.
This early settlement of Bulgarians was the reason Macedonia
and Epirus , i.e. Ilyrian Bulgaria ", to be called Old Bulgaria
in the 11th century; compared to Moesian Bulgaria (Bulgaria
with the capital of Pliska ), it is earlier. All this gives us
good ground to look for the beginnings of the Western Bulgarian
state Berzitia not in 680, when Kuber came from Srem in Western
Macedonia, rather almost two centuries earlier , i.e. in 495 with
the "taking on" of the "Lower Ohrid Land"
by Dragon, the Bulgarian.
Vitelianus , the military commander (referred to in various
sources as the Thracian, the Scythian , or the Getian), until
then in the service of the Byzantine army) , supported and assisted
by Theodoric the Great and Pope Hormisdas
turned against Byzantium in 506. Malala writes of his successful
campaign to the East ("The Lower Ohrid Lands") : At
the time of the same Emperor (Anastasius) the Thracian Vitelianus
, because of the expulsed bishops, took power and took Thrace
, Moesia and Scythia up to Odesos (present day Varna ?) and Anhialos
at the head of numerous Huns and Bulgarians. Namely this is mentioned
by the cosmographer from Ravena (end of the 6th c.) : "Inter
vero Thracian vel Macedoniam et Mysiam interiorem modo Bulgari
habitant qui ex supra scripta majore Scythia egresi sunt"
(Only Bulgarians , who came from the above mentioned Scythia
inhabit Thrace and Macedonia and Lower Moesia). However this is
not a departure, rather a form of a return , for a Medieval
Ohrid legend runs tat the Bulgarians ( known at that time as
the Brygoi ) lived around Olympus. The were driven
to the north and the east by Alexander the Great. A thousand years
later they returned to their compatriots and conquered Panonia
, Dalmatia, Ilyria, Macedonia, Thessaly and Thrice.
Theophilactus of Ohrid writes that Prince Boris-Michael
" by Divine inspiration took Kutmichevitza from Kotokion
and liberating it from the diocese , placed Dometa at its head".
This is a reference of the breaking away of the Kutmichevitza
region from the military and political district Kotokion, which
is another name of the state Berzitia (cited by Theophanes).
So far we lack further information on the political status of
Berezitia/Kotokion. Did it retain any independent status under
the rule of Dragon, Vitalianus , via Kuber and Akmir, even to
the time when it became part of Bulgaria, with a capital the
town of Pliska? Paul Lemerl , Ioachim Werner, Vladislav Popovic
refer to the concept "the state of Kuber". According
to some specialists it was in existence from 678 to 688, according
to others between 647/675 and 705. Facts point to it having created
much earlier than the arrival of Kuber , the Bulgarian, from
Srem , i.e. after the victory over the Byzantine Emperor by
Dragon, the Bulgarian Prince at the Tzurta river. From Vidin
Dragon passed through the Sofia plain and Kjustendil towards
the Vardar wishing to capture Thessalonike. The Tzurta river,
where the Bulgarian forces won a great victory, has been identified
with the present day Kriva reka, a tributary to the Pchinja ,
near Kumanovo.
The state of Berzitia (Kotokion) was situated between
the two fortresses Thessalonike and Dyrrachion - two important
military, administrative, and trade centres of Byzantium. Namely
the establishment of this state (495) and its expansion (538)
cut the road link between Thessalonike-Dyrrachion. Since then
the road known as via Egnatia ceased to exist for Byzantium.
In 584 a force of five thousand armed Blugariani
(Pseudo-obroi, , i.e.
Kotragoi and Slavs) attempted to capture Thessalonike . Two years
later (in
September 686) Thessalonike saw a second continuous siege. The
sieges of
Thessalonike which followed (609,620, and 622) are proof that
the Bulgarians (i.e.
"the Barbarians of a Slav creed"), following the "Scythian
delusion" settled for
long in the southwestern part of the Balkans between the Adriatic
and the Vardar
river. Namely these peoples held Epirus, Ilyria , Dardania, and
Macedonia. In
their organized life as a state near the port and fortress of
Thessalonke , these
peoples were in a position to undertake attacks. This is why
, 270 year later , in
the decisions of the Constantinople Church Council of 869-870,
these regions are
called the "Bulgarian homeland in Ilyria"